If Matthew Podolak died in 2006, the police did suspect that there was foul involvement. The autopsy concluded that he died of intoxication with ethylene glycol, but the cause of death was not verified. Four decades later, however, the story changed after a tip made by Cleveland Police.
Cleveland Police made them investigate the murder as “murder.” Method of death movie follows the horrific murder and how Matthew’s fiancée, Holly McFeeture, was the victim of a horrifying hate crime. If you’d like to learn more about the investigation as well as where Holly is at present, we’ve got the details.
Who is Holly McFeeture?
Her engagement was to fiancé Matthew Podolak, and the couple had two children. Additionally, the couple had a child from her previous relationship. She was a bartender at the Dirty Dog Tavern in Cleveland and also worked as an assistant coach for youth baseball.
When Holly was found out to be the killer, no one could understand why she poisoned her lover and then killed him in such a brutal way.
31st, 2006, Matthew Podolak died under strange circumstances of the poisoning of ethylene glycol. The chemical that killed him is usually the primary ingredient in antifreeze. Although the autopsy couldn’t determine the cause of death, the authorities were not able to establish any foul involvement.
Thus, the case was shut off and was not investigated as a murder. Authorities did find that Matthew was suffering from chronic alcoholism, which indicated that he consumed the drug regularly.
In 2010, four years following the murder, Cleveland police were notified of a report which claimed Matthew’s death wasn’t a suicide or an accident. The case was then revisited and was later deemed a homicide.
While investigating, the police spoke with Matthew’s friends, who stated that Matthew did not appear suicidal. The police also observed Holly’s behavior to be odd after her husband’s death.
Holly appeared to be in a relaxed mood in her comments, which was affirmed by a number of witnesses during her trial. Additionally, she unwittingly told a friend the fact that her husband utilized antifreeze to freeze his boat, but in actuality, Matthew’s boat broke down in either 2004 or 2005.
About a month following Matthew’s death, Holly began to date the policeman, Charles Lipscomb, and told him that Matthew was dead due to kidney issues. But, after an autopsy confirmed the reason for Matthew’s death, Holly expressed concerns about Matthew dying or being poisoned.
After looking into the cause of death over a period of two years, Holly McFeeture was arrested by authorities in July of 2012 and convicted of her husband’s murder aggravated and the contamination with a substance intended for consumption by humans.
The prosecution believed that she had mixed the antifreeze into Matthew’s ice tea with raspberry, which was consumed frequently by the victim. They also claimed that Matthew was poisoned over several months until Matthew eventually passed away.
Where is Holly McFeeture Currently?
When she was arrested and brought before the court, Holly McFeeture pleaded not guilty and went through an investigation. At her trial, a variety of witnesses were able to testify that they believed the couple and their fiancé were in the most difficult relationship, which frightened Matthew quite a bit.
The testimony also revealed the way Matthew had a positive outlook on the future and was not willing to take his own life. In addition, witnesses described how Holly did not seem to be affected by the death of her husband.
However, the most compelling witness was Jamison Kennedy. Kennedy was in a relationship with Holly in 2008. They met at the Dirty Dog Tavern and started an affair. Kennedy stated that Holly admitted to him that she had put Matthew’s drink in it and caused him to become sick.
He also said that Holly seemed to be “emotional” about her actions. In the final trial, jurors decided to find Holly McFeeture guilty of contaminating an ingredient intended for consumption by humans and of the aggravated crime of murder.
On the basis of her conviction, she was sentenced to 30 years or life imprisonment in 2013. Holly had been appealing her conviction but was rejected. She is now in the custody of the Ohio Reformatory for Women and will be scheduled for her parole hearing in 2043.